Well, that isn’t quite right. “Bullying” is just a sub-class of the tort we all know as intentional infliction of emotional distress.

According to press reports of the trial, the plaintiff perfusionist was the subject of a verbal attack by a heart surgeon. The plaintiff claimed that the attack forced him to leave his job.

The jury found the claim meritorious, and awarded the plaintiff $325,000. No punitive damages were awarded. In final argument, the plaintiff’s lawyer called the defendant “a domineering manager who viewed himself as untouchable” who “wanted to put [the plaintiff] in his place when the [he] threatened to tell hospital administrators that [the defendant] had verbally abused other members of his staff.” Read the post-trial press report here.

Call it a coincidence, but the General Assembly has passed a bill addressing the subject of bullying in schools. Read an article about it here. The bill requires school districts to develop a policy that prohibits harassment, intimidation or bullying.

To see the bill itself, click here and look up SB 1621 by Senator Black.

I am taking the weekend off. Those of you who are kind enough to stop by on Saturdays and Sundays (and there are scores of you who do) please know that I will be back on Monday morning.

I am going to Wisconsin (my home state) for a family reunion. Cheese curds and sausage for everyone!

Have a great weekend.

Expert witnesses. Can’t live with ’em. Can’t live without ’em. Can’t kill ’em.

Buy me a drink sometime and I will tell you expert witness stories that will make your head spin. Or, let me buy you a drink and I will bore you with the same stories.

But I must confess that I never had an expert I had difficulty reaching because he was in jail. That’s right: jail. Read the opinion.

Did you know that the Criminal Injuries Compensation Act has a subrogation provision?

T.C.A. Sec. 29-013-113 requires that a crime victim who receives payments under the Act and later receives damages in a civil action re-pay the State for monies received under the Act. If a civil action is filed the local DA and others must be sent a copy of the complaint and all subsequent pleadings.

Why? Because, unfortunately, part of the job of being a tort lawyer who represents patients and other negligence victims is staying on top of issues that affect current and future clients. I have monitored tort “reform” legislation since 1984. I have testified on our Capitol Hill numerous times since 1985; the first time concerned a bill that severely limited the liability of servers of alcoholic beverages (it passed, we lost).

The fact of the matter is that plaintiff’s lawyers are one of the few voices for malpractice victims. AARP is there. Labor is often there. But there is no “Future Wrongful Death Victims of America Association.” There is no “Prospective Med Mal Victims PAC.” No one ever thinks that they will be a victim of a negligent doctor, a careless truck driver, or a defective product, and therefore even the consumers who care about the issue are often unwilling to speak out about it – they have too many other things going on in their lives that demand attention today.

Therefore, it falls upon lawyers to advocate for victims, not just in the courtroom, but in the halls of the legislature. We have to run for the legislature (only 17 lawyers out of 132 legislators in Tennessee!) or, if we cannot, give monetary support to those who will. We have to find non-lawyers to serve as candidates, help them win, and help them understand that the same people who had the ability to cast the votes that put them into office are the people who serve as jurors. We have to help them understand that when a jury makes an error there is a judge there who can correct the error, and that if that judge makes an error we have an appellate court system to correct it. In summary, we have a system of checks and balances that, all things considered, works pretty dang well.

Public Citizen has just released new information that sets the record straight on various facts concerning medical negligence.

A few highlights:

1. At the same time that insurance rates in some areas have been climbing, the number and total value of malpractice payouts to patients have been flat since 1991 and, in fact, show a significant decline since 2001, when the spike in insurance rates began.

Thanks to Robert Ambrogi for telling us that the ABA Section of Litigation offers a free , weekly e-mail newsletter with litigation tips from James McElhaney.

McElhaney writes a regular article for the ABA publication Litigation (which, by the way, is one of the best litigation oriented magazines out there) and is the author of several books on trial techniques. Order the newsletter by clicking here.

Contact Information