Where a car accident plaintiff failed to properly serve the defendant driver before the claim against the driver was time-barred, the motion to dismiss filed by the plaintiff’s own uninsured motorist insurance carrier should have been granted.
In Dyer v. Haven, No. M2024-01364-COA-R9-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Aug. 21, 2026), the plaintiff filed suit against the defendant driver and his own uninsured motorist insurance carrier (“UM carrier”) after a car accident. In its answer, the UM carrier asserted that it had a statutory right to seek subrogation from the defendant driver.
The plaintiff and the UM carrier engaged in discovery for a year and a half. The UM carrier proceeded under the impression that the defendant driver had been properly served. At some point, however, the UM carrier discovered that the driver was never served. The plaintiff had attempted service twice and failed both times, and no alias summons was sought or issued.


