Uninsured Motorist Insurer Evades Case Because Plaintiff Did Not Get Service on Defendant

Where a car accident plaintiff failed to properly serve the defendant driver before the claim against the driver was time-barred, the motion to dismiss filed by the plaintiff’s own uninsured motorist insurance carrier should have been granted.

In Dyer v. Haven, No. M2024-01364-COA-R9-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Aug. 21, 2026), the plaintiff filed suit against the defendant driver and his own uninsured motorist insurance carrier (“UM carrier”) after a car accident. In its answer, the UM carrier asserted that it had a statutory right to seek subrogation from the defendant driver.

The plaintiff and the UM carrier engaged in discovery for a year and a half. The UM carrier proceeded under the impression that the defendant driver had been properly served. At some point, however, the UM carrier discovered that the driver was never served. The plaintiff had attempted service twice and failed both times, and no alias summons was sought or issued.

The UM carrier filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the plaintiff failed to properly serve the driver, and that “under Tennessee law a plaintiff cannot maintain a lawsuit against an uninsured motorist carrier if the court dismisses all claims against the allegedly uninsured motorist.” In response, the plaintiff requested an enlargement of time in which to serve the driver, asserting that the failure to serve the defendant was excusable neglect. The trial court granted the enlargement of time, but that ruling was reversed on appeal.

Under Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 6.02, a trial court may grant an enlargement of time for certain deadlines “where the failure to act was the result of excusable neglect.” The Tennessee Supreme Court has set out a four-factor test for determining whether a failure to meet a deadline was due to excusable neglect:

(1) the risk of prejudice to parties opposing the filing, (2) the delay and its potential impact on proceedings, (3) the reasons why the filings were late and whether the reasons were within the filer’s reasonable control, and (4) the good or bad faith of the filer.

(internal citation omitted).

Here, the plaintiff argued that the attorney’s office failed to file the returns of service because they were actively engaged in discovery with the UM carrier. The trial court found that there was no bad faith by the plaintiff, and although it acknowledged that the that the service was within the plaintiff’s control, it conflated the third and fourth factors and found that both factors weighed in favor of an excusable neglect finding since the action was “neither intentional nor deliberate.”

The Court of Appeals determined that the trial court misapplied the excusable neglect factors. The Court noted that the third factor has been described as potentially the “single most important of the four factors,” and that the good or bad faith of the parties does not weight into this factor. (internal citation omitted). Here, the third factor weighed against granting the enlargement, as the service of process issue was fully in the control of the plaintiff.

Further, the first factor weighed against granting the enlargement. The plaintiff’s failure to timely serve the driver was highly prejudicial to the UM carrier, as it caused the UM carrier to lose its potential subrogation rights against the driver. Looking to the four factors as a whole, the Court explained:

In sum, [the plaintiff’s] failure to properly serve [the defendant driver] did not delay the proceedings and was not an error born of bad faith. However, the avoidance of error was fully and entirely within the Plaintiff’s reasonable control, which is generally the most important consideration in assessing excusable neglect. Additionally, [the plaintiff’s] error arose from an errant understanding of law, which while not per se excluded from constituting excusable neglect will generally not provide a basis for such a finding. Additionally, for purposes of argument, we presume that this error prejudiced State Farm by extinguishing its right to subrogation against the actual tortfeasor. This left State Farm without recourse to recoup any monetary judgment entered against it in this case from the actual tortfeasor. Under these circumstances, the trial court’s decision to find excusable neglect and enlarge the time after the deadline had passed was error.

The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s grant of an enlargement of time within which to serve the defendant driver and remanded the case for dismissal.

Query:  would the failure of the plaintiff to serve the defendant impact State Farm’s subrogation rights against the defendant if State Farm was found liable to plaintiff?  Plaintiff effectively conceded that it would.  I am not so sure about that. And, given the language used by the Court of Appeals, I am not so sure it thinks the issue is as clear as the Plaintiff and State Farm think it is.

This opinion was released fourteen months after oral arguments in this case.

Contact Information