When is a motion to amend timely under Tennessee law?

A recent case discussed the timeliness of a motion to amend under Tennessee law.

In Pleasant v. City of Elizabethton, No. E2025-01067-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Aug. 27, 2026), the plaintiff filed suit under the Governmental Tort Liability Act (“GTLA”) after she tripped and fell on a raised portion of sidewalk while walking her dog. The trial court granted judgment on the pleadings and summary judgment to the defendant city, ruling that the plaintiff failed to allege that a government employee acted within the scope of his employment and failed to show that the city had actual or constructive knowledge of the defect. The Court of Appeals affirmed.

In her complaint, the plaintiff stated that her claim arose under Tenn. Code Ann. § 29-20-205. That section of the GTLA provides that “governmental immunity is removed when a government employee acting withing the scope of his or her employment causes an injury.” The plaintiff’s complaint, however only stated that the defendant city acted “through its employees and agents.” The plaintiff argued that this language was enough to satisfy Tennessee’s liberal pleading requirements, but the Court disagreed. The Court explained that “despite Tennessee’s generally liberal notice pleading standards, a GTLA claim brought under section 29-20-205 must expressly allege that the negligent conduct was committed by a government employee acting within the scope of his or her employment.” (internal citation omitted). The plaintiff’s complaint did not contain this overt allegation, so it failed to satisfy the pleading requirements of this section of the GTLA. Judgment on the pleadings was thus appropriate.

Plaintiff attempted to amend her complaint at the hearing on the motion, but the motion to amend was denied as untimely.  Plaintiff waited four years from the date the alleged deficiency in the complaint was first raised to move to amend.   The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s rejection of the motion to amend, saying as follows:

We observe that both parties attempt to use in their favor the more than three‑year span between the filing of the complaint and Plaintiff’s oral motion to amend. Plaintiff argues that because Defendant repeatedly raised the pleading deficiency in its answer in
2021, its amended answer in 2024, and its motion for judgment on the pleadings in March 2025, Defendant was aware of the issue and would not be prejudiced by amendment. Defendant, by contrast, contends that the same timeline shows undue delay by Plaintiff because despite repeated notice of the defect, she only sought leave to amend orally at the hearing on the dispositive motion.

The arguments are not equivalent. Plaintiff was put on notice of the fatal deficiency in her complaint very early in the case yet waited until the day of the hearing more than three years later to request leave to amend. Plaintiff offers no adequate explanation for the lengthy delay. Given the lack of adequate explanation, the trial court had a sufficient basis to find undue delay. Undue prejudice would likewise have resulted from allowing amendment at this late stage of the proceedings. Defendant had litigated under the same GTLA‑pleading defense for years, and a last-minute amendment would have forced it to extend its defense of the case without any adequate justification for Plaintiff’s delay.

This issue is reviewed for abuse of discretion, a highly deferential standard. The fact that another court might have ruled differently does not justify reversal; a discretionary decision stands unless the narrow criteria for finding an abuse of discretion are satisfied. Nothing in the record suggests that the trial court applied an incorrect legal standard; reached an illogical or unreasonable result; relied on a clearly erroneous assessment of the evidence; or employed reasoning that caused an injustice to Plaintiff. We therefore conclude that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying Plaintiff’s motion for leave to amend her complaint.

In other words, if a defendant asserts in an answer or an amended answer that there is a defect in the complaint, address it in a timely fashion.  Does a motion to amend need to be filed in one week? Certainly not.  One month?  Probably not.

But more than three years?  I mean, really, over three years?  Looking forward from today (after yesterday’s UT-LSU football game), four years is when Lane Kiffen may have a football record that LSU fans will accept as adequate.  But, then again, it won’t be at LSU because, if past is prologue, Kiffen will have coached a several different schools in the next four years and LSU fans won’t really care about his winning record at Burning Stump University.

The lesson:  if there is a problem, study your options.  Weigh the pros and cons of each option.  Pick the best option.  And implement your choice.

Sooner rather than later.

(Note:  I hasten to add that there was no harm to the plaintiff caused by this delay and the denial of the motion to amend.  A peculiar feature of GTLA law allowed an alternative statute to be considered to provide a basis for the claim.   My original point still is true:  see a problem, fix a problem.)

Contact Information