When a trial court’s denial of a TPPA petition for dismissal had been appealed, and the Court of Appeals had remanded the case with instructions for the trial court to enter an order containing sufficient findings of fact and conclusions of law, the plaintiff was not entitled to voluntarily dismiss…
Day on Torts
Plaintiff could not use reckless misconduct special duty exception in GTLA case.
The special duty exception to GTLA immunity did not apply where the police department in question owed a duty to investigate a crime to the public at large, and the plaintiff could not use the reckless misconduct special duty exception because the GTLA does not remove immunity for recklessness. In…
Dog Bite Statute does not always abrogate common law negligence claim
A Tennessee dog bite victim who cannot make a successful claim under the Tennessee Dog Bit Statute may not be precluded from pursuing a common law negligence claim. In Hudson v. Gravette, No. M2022-01787-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. May 8, 2025), the plaintiff was an employee at a dog boarding…
Intrusion upon seclusion claim survives death of plaintiff.
In Tennessee, a claim for invasion of privacy based on intrusion upon seclusion does not abate when the person whose privacy was invaded dies. In Jones v. Life Care Centers of America d/b/a Life Care Center of Tullahoma, No. M2022-00471-SC-R11-CV, — S.W.3d — (Tenn. April 25, 2025), Ms. Jones was…
No negligence by coach when cheerleader was injured in stunt.
Where a cheerleader was injured while doing a shoulder sit before a football game, the ruling that there was no negligence because the supervising teacher acted with reasonable care was affirmed. In Wherry v. Obion County Board of Education, No. W2024-00693-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. April 28, 2025), the plaintiff was…
No intentional infliction of emotional distress when the plaintiff was left at bus stop by bus driver.
A woman who was left at a bus stop in the cold by a bus driver did not state a claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress. In Williams v. Holt, No. M2024-01188-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. May 1, 2025), the plaintiff was waiting at a bus stop on a November…
Unchecked blanks made HIPPA authorization noncompliant.
Where a HIPAA authorization had blanks beside the names of all the providers listed under who was authorized to make disclosures, but none of the blanks were marked or checked, the HIPAA authorization was not compliant with the HCLA requirements. In Crenshaw v. Methodist Healthcare- Memphis Hospitals, No. W2024-00682-COA-R3-CV (Tenn.…
Quality Improvement Privilege (QIC) waivable in Tennessee.
Statements made that were related to a QIC meeting on a patient’s care were subject to the QIC privilege, but the hospital administrator waived that privilege to the extent he disclosed the privileged information to the patient’s family. In Castillo v. Rex, No. E2022-00322-SC-R11-CV (Tenn. May 9, 2025), the plaintiff…
Dismissal of defamation claim reversed.
In a case where a former Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation Deputy Commissioner claimed defamation based on statements related to a sexual harassment investigation and his subsequent termination, the Court of Appeals ruled that the State’s motion to dismiss should not have been granted, and that the State had…
Incomplete HIPAA authorizations lead to dismissal of HCLA claim.
Where an HCLA plaintiff provided incomplete HIPAA authorizations with his pre-suit notice, the trial court should have granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss. In Elmore v. Mills, No. E2023-01064-COA-R9-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Mar. 31, 2025), the plaintiff filed an HCLA suit against multiple defendants based on decedent’s death, who aspirated…